The Shuffle, Explained
The shuffle is the feature clubs love most. When a new innings starts, one tap re-balances the Gold and Silver groups based on how everyone just played — the in-form Silver players move up, the out-of-form Gold players move down. No spreadsheets, no arguments. This page covers exactly how it decides.
Step 1 — choose how many to swap
First the organizer picks how many players move each way. The choice is 0 to 5, and the default is 3. Call this number N.
- N = 0 — no shuffle; just start a fresh innings (groups unchanged).
- N = 3 (default) — the top 3 Silver players swap with the bottom 3 Gold players.
- Larger N mixes the groups more aggressively; smaller N keeps them stable.
Single-group clubs skip this step entirely — with one pool there is nothing to promote or relegate.
Step 2 — Rule 1: points-based swap
ScoreTally takes the top N players of Silver (by innings points) and promotes them to Gold, and the bottom N players of Gold and relegates them to Silver. Players carry their season points with them.
When two players are tied, selection uses this order:
- Higher points, then win %, then number of wins, then games played — all for the current innings.
- If still tied, the same four measures across the whole season.
- If still tied, a random pick (a toss).
Step 3 — Rule 2: the win-percentage swap
After the points swap, ScoreTally applies a second check to reward consistency. It looks only at players who played at least X games this innings (default 12):
- If the highest win % player is in Silver, they are promoted to Gold.
- The lowest win % player in Gold is relegated to Silver — regardless of how many games they played.
Players who didn't reach X games are skipped for promotion only — they can still be relegated from Gold if they have the lowest win %. If the highest Silver win % equals the lowest Gold win %, no win% swap happens.
Preview before you commit
The shuffle is not reversible, so ScoreTally shows a preview screen first: it lists exactly who moves up, who moves down, and any win% swap, before you confirm. Nothing is written until you tap through the final confirmation.
Worked example
The "Smashers" club just finished its January innings. They choose to shuffle N = 2. Here are the end-of-January innings points:
| Gold (pts) | Silver (pts) |
|---|---|
| Asha — 12 | Priya — 14 |
| Ben — 9 | Rahul — 11 |
| Carl — 5 | Sam — 6 |
| Dina — 3 | Tara — 2 |
Rule 1 (N = 2): top 2 Silver swap with bottom 2 Gold.
| Move | Players |
|---|---|
| Silver → Gold | Priya (14), Rahul (11) |
| Gold → Silver | Dina (3), Carl (5) |
Rule 2 (win %): suppose Sam (still in Silver, didn't get promoted) played 13 games at a 70% win rate — the highest win % in the club among players with ≥ 12 games — while Ben in Gold has the lowest win % at 40%. Sam is promoted; Ben is relegated.
| Group | After the full shuffle |
|---|---|
| Gold | Asha, Priya, Rahul, Sam |
| Silver | Ben, Carl, Dina, Tara |
A few house rules
- Any new member joins the Silver group.
- Guests can play, but their games are not counted toward points.
- A win scores 1 point; a loss scores nothing.